One of the most common questions I hear from teachers is, “How do I figure out what’s missing in my students’ reading skills? What steps should I take to help my 4th and 5th graders become skilled readers?”
You’re probably hearing a lot about the science of reading and various reading components, but what does it all mean for you and your specific students? How can you use actually it to address the unique challenges your students face?
I was curious too. The post you’re reading is the culmination of my 4+ years of studying the science of reading, specifically through the lens of what went wrong when I was teaching and what I should have done (and what I did right) based on the science.
Before we dive in, have you heard the quote that reading is rocket science? I agree with that.
And you can do this. With the right knowledge and support, you can make it easier.
However, be prepared that it is challenging because you’re going to see how all of these components work together. As a 4th and 5th grade teacher, it’s crucial to think of reading as rocket science so we can get to the root of it and really make a difference. I’m here to help you.
Let’s Get Started with our First Focus: Identifying and Addressing Reading Gaps in 4th and 5th Graders
Understanding the key components of reading is important for pinpointing exactly where your students need help.
I’m going to break down each of these components for you, explaining why they’re important, why they might be tricky, and how you can identify and address gaps in each area. Stick with me, and by the end of this, you’ll have a better understanding of where to start. But remember, this is just the beginning of the journey to supporting your students in becoming confident and fluent readers.
Here are the six essential components of reading based on science of reading and based on my understanding of how it impacts 4th and 5th grade reading instruction.
- Phonemic Awareness
- Phonics
- Vocabulary
- Fluency
- Comprehension
- Background Knowledge
These components are interconnected, and a struggle in one area often impacts others. So, while you might start with the most significant issue, it’s essential to address all areas to build a strong reader. Let’s get started by exploring each component in detail.
Note: While these components will be discussed separately, remember that they are interconnected and should be addressed in an integrated manner whenever possible.
Phonemic Awareness
Phonemic awareness is the ability to hear and manipulate sounds in words. By 4th and 5th grade, most students should have this skill firmly in place. However, if a student struggles here, it often indicates a need for deeper intervention.
Indicators:
- Phoneme Deletion: Can students accurately delete sounds from more complex words and still produce a recognizable word?
- Phoneme Substitution: Can students change one sound in a complex word to make a new word?
- Phoneme Reversal: Can students reverse the sounds in a word and recognize the new word?
Why is this important?
Phonemic awareness is foundational for reading and spelling. Without strong phonemic awareness, other reading skills will be harder to develop.
Why is it tricky?
By 4th and 5th grade, it’s not common for students to struggle with phonemic awareness. If they do, it suggests a significant gap that requires intensive, targeted support to build this foundational skill.
Note: While phonemic awareness issues are less common in 4th and 5th grade, they can still exist and should be addressed with appropriate interventions.
Phonics
Phonics involves understanding the relationship between letters and sounds. Most 4th and 5th graders should have basic phonics skills, but gaps can exist, especially with more complex patterns.
Indicators:
- Can students read multisyllabic words with complex phonics patterns accurately?
- Can students use phonics patterns or generalizations get to approximate pronunciations with unfamiliar words they encounter in texts?
- Can students accurately spell words with complex phonics patterns, including prefixes, suffixes, and root words?
Why is this important?
Strong phonics skills support vocabulary development and fluency.
Why is it tricky?
Phonics gaps are fairly common. These gaps often arise because students may not have received explicit phonics instruction. They might have memorized many words but struggle to transfer those skills to more difficult words. Additionally, they may not have learned to recognize word parts and how to flex vowel sounds to approximate pronunciation.
Personal Experience:
This one was really tricky for me during my fifth year of teaching. I had a lot of students who were stuck at a first or second grade reading level. They had the basics down, but they didn’t have anything beyond that, and I didn’t really know what to do. This makes phonics particularly tricky because sometimes you think students have the basics down, but they really don’t. Looking back now with this new knowledge, I wish I could have determined whether they actually had the basics. If they did, I would have built upon it with syllable type instruction to help them build automaticity by recognizing patterns. However, I now realize that they may have just memorized those words and not truly grasped the basics like I assumed.
Vocabulary
A strong vocabulary is essential for understanding what students read. They should be able to understand and use a wide range of words, both in conversation and in their reading.
Indicators:
- Can students use context clues to determine the meaning of unfamiliar words in a passage?
- Can students understand and use common prefixes, suffixes, and root words to determine the meaning of unfamiliar words? For example, understanding that “uncomfortable” means not comfortable.
- Can students accurately and appropriately use grade-level vocabulary in their writing and speaking?
- Can students decode and get to a really close but often funny approximation of the word? This could indicate they have a strong phonics background, but they don’t have the vocabulary. That’s the missing piece to get them to the next level.
Why is this important?
Vocabulary directly impacts comprehension. If students don’t understand the words they’re reading, they can’t fully grasp the meaning of the text. This makes vocabulary a key area to address. Additionally, if students have significant vocabulary gaps, those gaps have likely continued to widen over the years, making it even more challenging to catch up.
Vocabulary also impacts their ability to decode multisyllabic words because it hinders their ability to get an approximate pronunciation. With the English language requiring so much flexing of sounds with stressed and unstressed syllables and borrowed sounds, lacking the necessary vocabulary keeps their phonics skills at a lower level. They don’t have the word knowledge to recognize and decode more complex words accurately.
Why is it tricky?
Vocabulary gaps are common, but addressing them is far from simple. These gaps often stem from years of limited exposure to diverse and rich language, both in reading and in everyday conversations. By the time students reach 4th and 5th grade, these gaps can be quite significant and challenging to close. Building vocabulary requires thoughtful and intentional efforts from multiple angles, including direct instruction, exposure to rich texts, and meaningful conversations.
Something to Consider: Explicit vocabulary instruction, particularly in academic language and multiple word meanings, is extremely important.
Personal Experience:
In my first four years of teaching, I had students who could decode beautifully and even get approximate pronunciations, but their comprehension was not there. They had the decoding skills down, but they didn’t have the vocabulary. It was impressive to see them flex the sounds to get close to the correct pronunciation, sometimes producing funny approximations. However, they didn’t know the words, so their decoding skills weren’t as impactful as they could be.
On the flip side, my fifth year of teaching, I had students who had an amazing vocabulary, but it was limited to listening. They didn’t have the phonics skills to make use of that vocabulary, but vocabulary was a strength for them. I bring this up to point out that, yes, this seems like a lot, but your students do have strengths. Figuring out the root cause of what’s causing them the issue can allow them to use those strengths and improve upon them. They can actually become impactful readers. Don’t give up hope.
Fluency
Fluency is the ability to read with speed, accuracy, and proper expression. Many students may struggle with fluency, which impacts their overall reading comprehension.
Indicators:
- Can students read grade-level texts at an appropriate pace? This includes both silent and oral reading.
- Can students read aloud with proper expression, intonation, and phrasing, showing an understanding of the text’s meaning?
- Can students read with a high level of accuracy, making very few errors in pronunciation or word recognition?
Why is this important?
Fluency is crucial for comprehension because it allows students to focus on understanding the text rather than decoding each word. When students read fluently, they can better grasp the meaning of what they’re reading.
Why is it tricky?
Fluency issues are quite common, but they often mask other underlying problems. For example, a fluency problem might actually be a phonics problem or an issue with automaticity in decoding. If students are not decoding words automatically, it impacts their fluency. This makes it essential to dig deeper to find the root cause of the fluency issues.
Personal Experience:
In my experience, students who struggle with fluency often have underlying phonics issues. They might be able to read words correctly but not quickly or smoothly. This was a common challenge I faced in my classroom, where students could decode but not with enough automaticity to read fluently. Addressing these root causes helped improve their overall reading skills and comprehension.
Echo reading can be particularly tricky. For some students, it highlights their weaknesses, making them more self-conscious and less likely to participate. This is why some students might avoid reading aloud. While many students enjoy reading aloud, if a student doesn’t, it doesn’t always indicate a fluency issue, but it’s a good place to start. Don’t assume they just don’t want to read; investigate further to understand the root cause.
Something to Consider: Effective fluency practices, such as repeated reading and guided oral reading, can still enhance reading comprehension when done intentionally and keeping students’ challenges in mind.
Comprehension
Comprehension is the ultimate goal of reading – understanding and interpreting the text. By 4th and 5th grade, students should be able to think critically about what they read and make inferences if they’ve had strong, explicit instruction and the life experiences we expect them to have. But let’s be honest, many don’t.
Indicators:
- Can students accurately summarize a text and answer questions about it?
- Do they make connections between the text and their own experiences?
- Can students make inferences based on textual evidence and background knowledge?
- Can students evaluate and analyze a text, identifying the author’s purpose, point of view, etc.? (After initial skill instruction).
Why is this important?
Comprehension is the end goal of reading. If students can’t understand what they read, they can’t fully engage with the text or apply their knowledge in meaningful ways. Strong comprehension skills enable students to think critically and make inferences, which are essential for academic success.
Why is it tricky?
Comprehension issues often stem from weaknesses in other reading components. Here’s why it can be so tricky:
- Decoding: If students struggle with decoding, they spend too much mental energy trying to figure out the words, leaving little energy for understanding the text.
- Vocabulary: If students have a weak vocabulary, they don’t know the meaning of many words in the text, making it hard to grasp the overall meaning.
- Fluency: If students struggle with fluency, they read slowly and without proper expression, which disrupts the flow and makes it hard to follow the narrative or argument in the text.
And this isn’t all. There are other things that impact comprehension because, let’s be real, humans are complex creatures and our students are humans. Here are some other factors:
- Background Knowledge
- Attention and Focus
- Inference Skills
- Motivation and Interest
- Text Structure Awareness
- Metacognitive Strategies
- Language Proficiency
I’m giving you this list because it provides choices and options for what you can actually do. Yes, it’s daunting, but we have options. Yeah!
Personal Experience:
I’ve seen many students who could read words correctly but still struggled with comprehension. They could decode and read fluently, but when asked to summarize or answer questions about the text, they couldn’t do it. Often, this was due to gaps in their vocabulary or an inability to connect what they were reading to their own experiences. By addressing these gaps, I was able to help students improve their comprehension and become more confident readers.
Something to Consider: Explicit instruction in comprehension strategies like questioning, summarizing, predicting, and inferring can still be impactful while building other skills.
Background Knowledge
Background knowledge is the information and experiences that readers bring to a text. It helps them make sense of what they read. This isn’t typically included as one of the important pillars, but it really is.
Indicators:
- Can students connect new information to what they already know about a topic, enhancing their understanding of the text and the topic?
- Can students make connections between texts and topics across different subjects, such as relating a science text to something they learned in social studies?
- Can students understand and use vocabulary specific to different content areas, such as science, social studies, and literature?
Why is this important?
Background knowledge gives students the context they need to understand what they’re reading. It helps them make connections, understand vocabulary, and follow the flow of the text. Without it, students might struggle to make sense of even simple texts.
Why is it tricky?
Background knowledge impacts so many areas. It affects decoding because students can’t get an approximate pronunciation of a word if they don’t know it. It impacts vocabulary because without background knowledge of a context or topic, students don’t have the necessary words. This, in turn, affects their fluency and comprehension. So, yes, it’s tricky, but this is why I wanted to include it and why I put it last—it really impacts all the other ones. The good news? It’s not easy, but we can do some things to help.
Personal Experience:
I’ve had students who struggled with comprehension not because they couldn’t decode or didn’t have the vocabulary, but because they lacked the background knowledge needed to understand the text. For example, reading a passage about farming would be difficult for a student who has never been exposed to farming concepts. By building their background knowledge through discussions, multimedia resources, and related readings, I was able to help them better understand and engage with the texts.
Something to Consider: Building background knowledge is an ongoing process.
Wrapping It Up
Understanding and addressing the different components of reading—phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, comprehension, and background knowledge—can feel overwhelming. But remember, you’re not alone in this journey, and every small step you take makes a difference.
Identifying where your students struggle the most is the first step. Use the indicators we’ve discussed to pinpoint the areas that need attention. This is why it’s so important—addressing these foundational skills can transform your students into confident, fluent readers.
Stay tuned for more tips and strategies on how to support your students. You’ve got this!
Where Are Your Sources for This?
I’m glad you asked!
My approach is all about quickly turning research into practical tools for you and your students. While I might not always track every source meticulously, it’s because I’m focused on making real connections and putting knowledge into action. I’ve read a lot and have a solid grasp of the material, even if my citation game isn’t perfect. Rest assured, my insights are research-based and aimed at helping you make a real difference in the classroom.
Leave a Comment